How Right at Home Columbia Replaced Their Answering Service With Phoebe

Company
Right at Home Columbia
Scheduling system
WellSky
Hired Phoebe
April 2026

Mike Brown is the majority owner of Right at Home Columbia, a family business his parents started in Columbia, South Carolina 21 years ago. He joined close to 15 years ago and worked his way into operations. Today the agency serves close to 200 clients a week, about 70% private pay and about 20% veterans through VA programs, with three full-time schedulers in the office.

For many years, an answering service covered the phones after hours. Messages reached the team late, and the service cost more than $1,000 a month. Right at Home Columbia now uses Phoebe for all of its after-hours calls, and the answering service bill is gone.

"When you're running a small business, every single dollar counts. I'm able to take off over a thousand dollars a month in just an answering service, and now I have Phoebe answering my after hours, but it's reacting to things that are happening."

— Mike Brown, Owner, Right at Home Columbia

After hours was one piece. Phoebe also fills shifts, sends shift reminders, follows up on missed clock-ins and clock-outs, reminds caregivers to complete their tasks, and answers the main line as an auto attendant.

Results at a glance

Before PhoebeWith Phoebe
After-hours callsAnswering service, with delays in messages reaching the teamPhoebe answers and follows the agency's own protocols
Answering service costMore than $1,000 a monthEliminated
Clock-ins and clock-outs recorded78%93%
Finding a caregiverUp to 30 phone calls, one at a timePhoebe calls and texts caregivers at the same time
Change requestsWeeksUsually in place within 24 to 48 hours

The challenge: a 24/7 business run on pen, paper, and an answering service

Mike calls the time before Phoebe "the dark days." Scheduling ran on the agency's scheduling software, and everything around it lived on paper or in someone's head.

"In the home care business, things change in a second. Your caregiver availability changes, your client availability changes. Finding a way to keep all that data in one place is extremely challenging."

The stakes of getting it wrong are high. Families have plenty of agencies to choose from, and one bad match can end a relationship.

"All it takes is putting the wrong person in the wrong shift, and you run the risk of losing that client. You really have to almost run flawlessly in order to keep all your clients in place."

The work also never stops. Right at Home Columbia provides care around the clock, so calls come in at every hour. For many years those calls went to an answering service, and Mike's biggest concern was how long the messages took to reach his team.

Mike heard about Phoebe from other owners in the Right at Home system who had already tried it. Their feedback made the decision simple.

"It's almost one of those things you can't afford not to try. It's a very low risk scenario. If it doesn't work, okay, you gave it a shot. You're not spending a year's worth of investment doing it."

Replacing the answering service with the agency's own playbook

Right at Home Columbia did not hand Phoebe a generic script. The team took its own playbook and best practices for after-hours calls and gave them to the Phoebe team, who built them into the protocols Phoebe follows.

"You tell Phoebe exactly what you want it to do, and Phoebe's going to do it."

The rollout was careful. The agency started with Phoebe covering after hours every other day. When something did not work the way they wanted, they told the Phoebe team, the team fixed it, and they tried again. Today Phoebe handles all of the agency's after-hours calls.

"Now at this point, we're just solely using Phoebe for doing the after hours, and it's been really good. Nothing falls through the cracks. That's important to us."

Phoebe answers, forwards calls, and sends messages in the patterns the agency chose, and the team can adjust those patterns at any time. Messages also go into the internal text messaging service the office already uses. If one person misses a message, Mike says three or four other protocols are in place to make sure it is caught.

An answering service takes a message. Phoebe acts on what it hears.

"If a caregiver is calling to cancel, it remembers that this caregiver is sick, so we can't put them in the schedule."

Three schedulers and a teammate

Right at Home Columbia still has three full-time schedulers. When the agency rolled Phoebe out, Mike made the purpose clear to them from the start.

"It's important for people to know that this is not here to take your job. This is here to help you. This is here to make us more efficient."

The schedulers now split the work with Phoebe the way they would with a colleague: Phoebe handles these, I'll handle this. Phoebe takes the bulk outreach, and the office keeps the conversations that need a person.

"The 30 phone calls that you have to make to try to find a caregiver, Phoebe does it simultaneously. You start thinking of all this precious time that you're buying back so that your staff can focus on the person to person contact."

A memory the whole office shares

Phoebe has thousands of calls and texts with the agency's caregivers in some weeks, and it keeps what it learns: availability, changes, and preferences. Before, that knowledge depended on who happened to take the call.

"I spoke to Sally, and she said, I don't want to do this. But maybe she only spoke to you. The entire office doesn't know that. Phoebe remembers every single conversation that it's had."

That memory does not stay inside Phoebe. When a caregiver tells Phoebe their availability has changed, Phoebe writes the update back to WellSky. The schedulers see the same information in the scheduling system they already work in, without anyone retyping it.

A second opinion on hard schedules

The schedulers also ask Phoebe for help when they are stuck. If a client's three preferred caregivers are all booked, Phoebe can suggest what to move to free one of them up.

"While it's not going to do it for you, it'll give you a plan A, plan B, plan C. And now all of a sudden, everyone's a critical thinker."

Clock-ins and clock-outs: from 78% to 93% recorded

Much of the agency's billing depends on caregivers clocking in, clocking out, and documenting their tasks. Long-term care policies require it, and families check the portal to see what they are paying for.

"When you have a few hundred shifts a day that are being completed, it's physically impossible for someone to be making those calls."

Phoebe knows when a clock-in or clock-out is missing and texts or calls the caregiver to get it done. Account data reviewed for the interview shows the share of clock-ins and clock-outs recorded rose from 78% to 93%.

Caregivers have learned what to expect.

"Until you start doing it on your own, you're going to get a phone call and a text message from Phoebe. You can yell at Phoebe all you want. Phoebe will continue to call you and say thanks, have a great day."

Ready for the next wave of demand

Mike expects demand for home care to peak over the next five to six years, and he thinks most agencies will be running 30 to 40% more hours than they do today. He does not want to meet that growth with four or five more schedulers and a bigger office.

"It's not a matter of, are you going to have the volume? It's how are you going to manage it? Unless you want to run a business where you have a call center full of people doing this, it's not feasible."

With Phoebe carrying the repetitive work, his team can spend its time on home visits and conversations with clients. His advice to other owners is direct.

"If you're not on board with using a system like this, you're going to be falling way, way far behind."

"I couldn't imagine not using it now. We'd be in big trouble if we didn't have it."

Start Scheduling with Phoebe

Book a demo and we'll discuss how Phoebe can help your team and create a tailored plan for your company.